The placement of 83 Vaci Street has a turn key structure attached to it, designed
to give investors tax relief at a rate of 58c on the Euro, by purchasing the property
through a self administered trust. This allows investors to effectively purchase a
€200,000 apartment for €116,000.
The following explains how a self administered trust operates:
Self Directed Pension Trusts:
Key Benefits:
- The transfer of money from a company into a Trust will not result in a personal
tax liability for the individual company director.
- The individual is the sole beneficiary of the Trust.
- The assets of the Trust cannot be accessed by creditors in the event of company failure.
- Current profits and retained earnings in the company can be transferred into the
Trust for the benefit of the director.
- The Trust can invest in areas of personal interest to the director including property,
private companies, equities, gilts, tracker bonds, deposits, investment funds, etc.
- Investments can grow free of Income Tax and Capital Gains Tax.
- The involvement of the director in the management of the Trust depends entirely on the
level of personal interest. It can be a hands-on or hands-off arrangement. Investment expertise is not necessary.
- Benefits can be drawn directly from the Trust at retirement commencing at age 50.
Return to Top
Retirement/Fund Extraction Options:
- Funds can be accessed:
- At age 60
- At age 50 (if you retire)
- At any age (if you retire due to ill health)
- On death
- In each case some or all of the Fund can be taken as a Tax Free Lump Sum. This amounts to:
- 1.5 times salary on retirement or
- 25% of the Fund if you choose your Proprietary Director options (see below).
- 4 times salary on death.
- The balance of the Fund (if any) can be used in one or more of the following ways
- Full encashment, subject to tax at marginal rates (not available on death)
- Annuity purchase
- Transfer to an ARF (Approved Retirement Fund- see below).
Under your Proprietary Director options, a transfer to an ARF is not taxable. Profits and Gains
of the ARF are not taxable. Withdrawals from the ARF will be subject to Income Tax. This is
collected under the PAYE system. An ARF inherited by children over 21 will be exempt from
Inheritance Tax but is subject to PAYE at the standard rate. An ARF inherited by children under
21 is exempt from Income Tax but is potentially liable to Inheritance Tax.
Return to Top
Property Investing Via a Trust
Investment criteria: One of the key benefits of a Self-Directed Pension Trust is its ability to invest
in real property. The Revenue Commissioners have introduced some criteria that
specifically apply to property investment:
- The vendor must be at arm's length from the scheme and the
employer including its directors and associated companies.
- The purpose of the acquisition is not for disposal or letting to the
employer, including its directors and associated companies.
- The scheme must have sufficient liquid investments to meet its liabilities.
- The acquisition and development of a property with a
view to its disposal is not regarded as a tax-exempt scheme investment.
- The acquisition of property for personal use (rather than for investment purposes) is prohibited.
Once these criteria are satisfied a scheme can invest in any type of property based anywhere
in the world. This can include residential, office and industrial buildings.
Investment Procedure: A solicitor is identified to handle the transaction on behalf
of the Self-Directed Trust. The funds required to finalise the purchase are transferred from
the Trust Bank Account to the solicitor's client account in order to permit the discharge of the initial
deposit and the balance of the purchase monies.
The initial contract can be signed by any Trustee (in trust) on behalf of the Trust. The
formal transfer of title will be signed by all Trustees. The title to the property will be
in the joint names of the Trustees. It can also state that it is held on behalf of the
relevant Trust.
The stamp duty and legal fees can be paid by the Trust or by the employing company.
Payment of fees by the employing company can allow VAT to be recovered. Payment of stamp
duty by the Trust may effectively give a tax deduction on this capital item. Whilst it is
technically possible for the Trust to register for VAT, in practice this route is usually only taken in respect of commercial properties.
The title deeds to the property can be retained by the purchasing solicitor as custodian
for the Trust. A note confirming this should be issued by the solicitor.
Expenses and Income: In some cases, an agent is appointed to manage the investment
property. The income from the property can be paid to the agent and expenses appropriate to
the property discharged from the income. The balance should be paid to the Trust Bank Account
for further investments. Details of gross income and expenditure should be provided annually
by the agent for the preparation of the Trust's annual report.
Return to Top
Foreign Property Investment:
Revenue Criteria: The Revenue permit a Self-Directed Trust to invest in all forms of property
including residential property based in Ireland and overseas. The key criterion it that the property
must be used for investment purposes, i.e. it cannot be used by the individual for personal purposes.
The approval by the Irish Revenue of a Self–Directed Trust receives generous tax treatment in Ireland.
It is exempt from all Capital Gains Tax and Income Tax.
This tax treatment is also preserved in respect of UK investment as a result of the Ireland UL tax treaty.
However, similar exemption is not readily available in other jurisdictions such as Spain, Portugal etc.
As a result, tax will be payable at source. We provide advice on how the local jurisdictions operate.
Other Requirements: The laws and taxes of the overseas jurisdiction in which an investment is made
will need to be complied with. In this context, therefore, it will be necessary for the investment by this
Self-Directed Trust to be structured in such a way as to ensure that all criteria are complied with and that
the trustees are protected from any obligations that may arise in this regard. In this context, therefore, it
is usual to see a company used for the purposes of effecting the investment in the foreign jurisdiction, i.e.
the pension fund invests in a company (usually based outside of Ireland) which, in turn, purchases the property overseas.
Thus, the asset of the pension fund will be the shares in the company.
This arrangement offers the following benefits:
- The Trustees are protected from direct exposure to the tax and legal impositions of the local jurisdiction.
- The complexity of dealing with a Trust in jurisdictions which do not recognize them is avoided.
- Legal and taxation implications in relation to succession and death charges in those overseas jurisdictions will also be avoided.
It should be noted that the benefits of the company structure must
be ascertained in each circumstance, as changes in legislation and differences between
jurisdictions will alter the impact of the structure.
One advantage that can result from the use of the corporate structure is the
possibility that the overseas company can utilize borrowing to assist in the property purchase.
The appropriateness of going this route is a matter for the professional advisers to the Trust
Trustee Requirements:
Where it is proposed to purchase property on behalf of a Self-directed Trust it is necessary that
a solicitor is appointed in Ireland who will advise the trust in relation to the proper acquisition
of title and other financial and legal matters arising from the purchase. Also all funds for investment
in the property (or in the overseas company) will be transferred through the solicitor and moved onwards
on the direction of that solicitor.
The trustees are required to have joint signing authority on the Trust accounts, and it is also
appropriate that they would have similar authority in relation to the company’s bank.
Suitable arrangements would need to be put in place in relation to the maintenance and operation of
the property, the maintenance and discharge of fiscal and legal obligations in relation to the property,
and the title to the property.
The costs of the structures can ultimately be borne by the Trust as they are incurred on behalf of the
Trust. This includes the fees of the relevant advisors, which should be confirmed in advance.
Return to Top